Florida’s Nature Coast supports one of the Gulf’s largest seagrass meadows and is a popular destination for fishing and boating. However, propeller scarring poses a growing threat to these seagrass beds. The SCAR MAPS (Seagrass Conservation through Actionable Research: Management Areas for the Prevention of Scarring) project investigates spatial management strategies to mitigate this impact. One potential solution is the implementation of seagrass management zones, such as pole and troll areas. To inform this approach, we conducted 18 semi-structured interviews with managers, law enforcement, and other end-users involved in similar efforts across Florida. We also completed multiple site visits to established pole and troll zones to observe design, enforcement, and community engagement practices. A literature review characterizes research findings and recommendations related to seagrass damage caused by recreational boating worldwide. Analysis of interview transcripts revealed consistent priorities: the need for robust data, transparent processes, and inclusive end-user engagement. Site observations highlighted practical considerations for signage, access, and compliance. Together, these insights will inform decisions and end-user engagement processes for seagrass management zones in Florida’s Nature Coast. This integrated approach can enhance conservation outcomes while maintaining recreational access, ensuring the resilience of these vital ecosystems for future generations.